The Eternal State ~ Advaita Nonduality

03 oct 08 - two essays on not knowing

the heart is where your home is | writings | basics | pointers | archives 2009 | dialogues

03 Oct 2008 - Two Essays on Not Knowing

Who Knows?

Many years ago a wise peasant farmer lived in China.

He had a son who, though an idiot, was the gleam in his eyes - he certainly adored the  boy as only a parent can. He also had one horse - a beautiful horse, which was not only his favorite and beloved possession, but also the workhorse for the farm.

One day the idiot son left the corral gate open and the horse escaped from his grounds and disappeared into the fields outside the village.

The villagers came to him one by one and announced their condolences. They said, "You are such an unlucky man. It is such bad fortune”"

The peasant answered, "Who knows. Maybe it's bad luck, maybe it's good fortune."

The neighbors shrugged and left.

The next day the horse returned, followed by twelve wild horses who followed him into the corral; the farmer noticed this, smiled, and securely locked the corral gate, warning his son, "please dear boy, do NOT leave the gate unlocked again". The boy promised to do his best.

The same neighborly people returned and told our wise man about how lucky he was. "It's such great good fortune”!

The wise man replied once more, "Who knows. Maybe it's good fortune, maybe it is not. Who knows”?

As it happened, the next day his one and only son was attempting to break in one of the wild horses when the horse threw the boy and the boy broke his leg.

Once more everyone came to console him. They said, "It's so bad."

Again the farmer replied, ""Who knows. Maybe it's bad, maybe it's good."

Three days passed and his poor idiot son was limping around the village with his broken leg, when the emperor's army entered the village announcing that a war was starting and they conscripted all the young men of the village for a suicidal battle against overwhelming odds. However, they left the son since he had a broken leg.

Once more, everyone was so jealous of our wise man. They surrounded him talking about his shier luck. "It is so good for you," they said. He answered all thus, ""Who knows. Maybe it's wonderful, maybe it's terrible. WHO KNOWS"?

And obviously - the story goes on -  forever.

Who claims to know, knows NOT. – Ancient saying


The brilliance of NOT knowing:

Listen to Jeff Foster's Interview on "Urban Guru Cafe"



The Train

Every four years in the USA we hear the same argument. This train we called the world, life, as we know it, is headed to a bad place, and if we don’t heed the old Chinese wise man who said “If we don’t change direction we will end up where we are headed – the abyss of destruction of life as we know it”.

And unless you all come over to MY side of the train (the left or right side of the train) we will be destroyed.

But what we ignore is this train is on TRACKS. We talk change but changing the side on which we all sit on the train has never made any real difference. But we don’t notice that!

Look: Whether we are all sitting on the Left side or Right side, the train is still on TRACKS.

So what must happen?

This train is headed to the abyss; what must happen?

The unthinkable.

We must go out – way out – in FRONT of the train, and install new track to a different destination, along with a switch to divert the train before it gets to the abyss.

How, you ask, can we DO this?

Nobody knows.

Maybe – just maybe – in NOT knowing – NOT knowing for example, that the Left is the correct side or the Right is the correct side to sit on this death train – maybe, just maybe, giving up this arrogance of our knowing – possibly (I don’t know!) in this space of Unknowing – there abides the possibility which is unthinkable – to lay new track for the train on which the arguers of a position for either the Left or the Right can ride to a brighter future.

Who knows?

Thanks to Werner Erhard, who gave a talk in 1982 which I heard at that time, and which inspired this essay. If you’d like to listen to a recording of that talk Click HERE Now.


(Fair Use)


Get Our Free "Nowsletter"

Your e-mail will never be shared or sold

To Get a Weekly Nonduality "Nowsletter", Register Here


Heart To Heart Donations ~ If you'd like to donate to support the message you may do so with this button. Just fill in any amount from (minimum) US $5 up. (NOTE - Donations to The Eternal State - Advaita Nonduality are not tax-deductible for U.S. federal income tax purposes). If you prefer, you can mail a check or money order for any amount you want to offer to Charlie Hayes, 1111 S. Oakwood Rd. #1308, Enid OK 73703.


home  | consultations |  writings | talks | audio-video | nonduality books | site map | links



Legal Noise: This web site and our newsletter may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. If you are the owner of some material appearing and wish to have it removed please contact and it shall be done asap.


NOTE If there is persistent and deep psychological suffering, please make sure there is not a physical component. If you have thoughts of suicide there may be a mechanical element ... get a good physician and/or psychiatrist (NOT a psychologist) to look at the machine and see if it has some chemical imbalance. Non-duality is NOT a substitute for proper medical assessment and care!